Montana Wheat & Barley Logo

Objective:                  

To evaluate herbicide combinations on weed control performance in spring wheat in environments and cropping systems representative of northwestern Montana     

Personnel:                 

Clint Beiermann, Lovreet Shergill, Jessica Pavelka

Summary:

Spring wheat was planted on April 27th, 2022 and thirteen different herbicide combinations were tested, with a non-treated as a control (Tables 1 & 2). 

Treatments (2) Sharpen fb Axial Star, (5) Anthem Flex fb Axial Star, (6) Prowl fb Axial Star, (7) Axial Star, (8) Axial Star + Affinity TankMix, (9) Axial XL + Talinor + CoAct+, (10) Huskie + Axial XL, (11) Opensky, (12) Opensky + 2,4-D, and (13) Varro + Fluroxypyr all provided greater than 90% wild oat control. Treatments (3) Zidua and (14) WideMatch + Affinty TankMix had 30% or less control, while treatment (4) Zidua fb Axial Star had an average of 78% control (Table 3). All herbicide treatments applied, excluding treatment (3) Zidua, resulted in a high level of lambsquarter control.

Weed density was assessed four weeks after the final post treatments were applied. Wild oat was only present in the treatments (1) non-treated, (3) Zidua, (4) Zidua fb Axial Star, (12) Opensky + 2,4-D, & (14) WideMatch + Affinity (Table 4). Lambsquarter density was higher in treatments with poor control performance, including (2) Sharpen fb Axial Star, (3) Zidua, (4) Zidua fb Axial Star, (5) Anthem Flex fb Axial Star, (7) Axial Star, and (13) Varro + Affinity TankMix(Table 4). Treatment (7) Axial Star had an even higher density of lambsquarter than the non-treated, indicating little to no control.

Crop injury was generally low across treatments, excluding treatment (9) Axial XL + Talinor + CoAct+, (11) Opensky, and (12) Opensky + 2,4-D. These treatments caused 36.5-47.5% injury at two weeks after treatment (Table 5). The yields from treatments 9 and 11 were statistically less than many of the other treatments, indicating the injury may have influenced the yield (Table 5). There was a significant effect of herbicide treatment on spring wheat yield. Treatments (1) non-treated, (3) Zidua, (9) Axial Xl + Talinor + CoAct+, (11) Opensky, and (14) WideMatch + Affinty TankMix resulted in yield lower than other treatments.  The yields ranged from 66.6 bu/A to 98.0 bu/A with non-treated and (13) Varro + Fluroxypry, respectively.

 

Table 1. Management Information

Seeding date: 4/27/2022 Field Location: R6
Julian date: 117 Harvest date: 8/23/2022
Seeding rate: NA Julian date: 235
Previous crop: Alfalfa Soil type: Creston Silt Loam
Herbicide: 4/22, 5/9, 6/2 Tillage: Conventional
Insecticide: NA Soil residual nutrient (NO3-1, P, K lb/A): 78.5-6-122
Fungicide: NA Nutrient fertilizer applied (N, P2O5, K20 lb/A): 80-50-60-10s

 

Table 2. Spring Wheat Wild Oat & Kochia Herbicide - Treatments

Trt No. Treatment Name Rate Rate Unit Appl Timing
1 Non-treated      
2 Roundup 32 fl oz/a PRE
  Sharpen 4 fl oz/a PRE
  Axial Star 16.4 fl oz/a POST
3 Roundup 32 fl oz/a PRE
  Zidua 1.5 oz wt/a PRE
4 Roundup 32 fl oz/a PRE
  Zidua 1.5 oz wt/a PRE
  Axial Star 1.75 fl oz/a POST
5 Anthem Flex 2.75 fl oz/a PRE
  Axial Star 16.4 fl oz/a POST
6 Prowl 1.5 pt/a Early POST
  Axial Star 16.4 fl oz/a POST
7 Axial Star 16.4 fl oz/a POST
8 Axial Star 16.4 fl oz/a POST
  Affinity TankMix 1 oz wt/a POST
9 Axial XL 16.4 fl oz/a POST
  Talinor 13.7 fl oz/a POST
  CoAct+ 2.75 fl oz/a  
10 Huskie 11 fl oz/a POST
  Axial XL 16.4 fl oz/a POST
11 Opensky 1 pt/a POST
12 Opensky 1 pt/a POST
  2,4-Dester LV6 7 fl oz/a POST
13 Varro 6.85 fl oz/a POST
  Fluroxypyr 0.3 pt/a POST
14 WideMatch 1 pt/a POST
  Affinity TankMix 1 oz wt/a POST
* Included in each POST application
  AMS 17 lb/100 gal  
  NIS 0.25 % v/v  

 

Table 3. Weed Control (6 WAT)

Treatment Wild Oat Lambsquarter
  % %
2 99.0 92.0
3 30.0 64.5
4 78.8 91.8
5 99.0 92.0
6 99.0 96.8
7 99.0 90.8
8 99.0 99.0
9 99.0 99.0
10 99.0 99.0
11 99.0 99.0
12 99.0 99.0
13 99.0 99.0
14 22.5 99.0
Mean 86.3 93.9
CV 8.8 13.2
LSD 10.8 17.8
PR>F <0.001 0.025
Bold = highest value in column; Bolding denotes equal value to highest or earliest value within a column based on LSD(0.05), WAT = weeks after treatment

 

 

Table 4. Weed Density (4 WAT)

Treatment Wild Oat Lambsquarter
  plants/m2 plants/m2
1 12.3 13.0
2 0.0 50.
3 3.3 5.8
4 0.3 3.8
5 0.0 4.8
6 0.0 0.0
7 0.0 18.5
8 0.0 1.0
9 0.0 0.0
10 0.0 0.3
11 0.0 0.3
12 0.3 1.3
13 0.0 4.0
14 11.8 0.0
Mean 2.0 4.1
CV 101.9 99.5
LSD 2.9 5.8
PR>F <0.001 <0.001
Bold = highest value in column; Bolding denotes equal value to highest or earliest value within a column based on LSD(0.05), WAT = weeks after treatment

 

 

Table 5. Crop Injury & Yield

Treatment Injury (%) Yield
  2 WAT (bu/A)
1 0 66.6
2 5 92.5
3 2.5 88.4
4 3.8 92.3
5 7.3 93.4
6 6 91.7
7 6 91.8
8 3.8 90.6
9 47.5 85
10 11 93.4
11 43 87.1
12 36.5 89.3
13 4.5 98
14 4.3 70.8
Mean 13.9 88.2
CV 14.1 7.3
LSD 2.8 -
PR>F <0.001 <.001
Bold = highest value in column; Bolding denotes equal value to highest or earliest value within a column based on LSD(0.05), WAT = weeks after treatment